Is A Metal Roof Better Than Shingles On A Shed?

Hello friends how are you all? Today we are going to talk about Is A Metal Roof Better Than Shingles On A Shed? If you are planning to purchase a new shed or replace your roof on the existing shed, you would need to decide between many options of the roofing material you would want to use.

Is A Metal Roof Better Than Shingles On A Shed?

The choice usually varies between asphalt shingles or metal roofings when it comes to sheds. These two materials are the most popular options for storage shed roofs. However, which one would be better? Let’s find out.

Benefits of using shingles

Shingles are very common in houses nowadays, and they are more likely to be used to make the shed match your house. They provide a great texture along with the dimension in each single. There are variations in the colors and shingle sizes as well.

It is important to know that shingles tend to absorb heat from the shed, so they are warm in winter than metal roofing. Here are some of the greatest benefits of going for shingles for your shed:

Color and style

Shingle roofs have too many types, i.e., the architectural and the three-tab. Both of these look great and are easily available to match the roof at your house. The shingled roofs come in many varieties of colors and sizes, and you can always match the shingles with the existing house.


Expense is always an important thing to consider when deciding on your options. First of all, it is important to know that shingles usually cost less and are known to be relatively more affordable than metal. If you install the shingles made of asphalt, it will be even more affordable.

Maintaining the shingles

Another good reason to go for shingles is that they are extremely easy to use, repair, and replace. In case of a leakage, you would only need to replace the damaged sections instead of the whole shingle. There is no requirement for special equipment to install these shingles, and when you repair them, you wouldn’t need to spend on any fancy equipment either.

Drawbacks of using shingles

As we already talked about shingles being able to absorb heat, you would know that this is as much of an advantage as it is a disadvantage. In summers, the shingles would absorb more heat than the metal shingles, increasing the temperature.

Moreover, the shingles tend to be petroleum-based products that aren’t eco-friendly. They are susceptible to wind damage and can grow moss and algae when the environment is damp.

You can explore the drawbacks of the shingles further through the following:


Considering durability, the shingles can last only 10-15 years. Even if they are inexpensive to install, they would still need to be replaced after a few years. Hence, the cost should be measured as well.

Weather resistance

The shingles are sensitive to high heat due to the absorption of more heat than the shed with metal roof. They are also sensitive to the rapid swings in temperature and can become brittle due to the heat. Moreover, they can also break off in high winds.

The environmental impact

As shingles are petroleum-based, their manufacturing process has a lot of negative impacts on the environment, due to which they can’t be recycled. They end up in landfills due to not being recycled and then contributing to pollution.

Benefits of metal roofing

Metal roofs are known to last much longer than shingle roofs, and they are also more lightweight in nature. Due to it being more durable, people consider using a metal roof on a shed, even if it is not as cost-effective as the shingles.

Moreover, it is a much more eco-friendly option, as compared to the shingle, and can be made of recycled material as well. Here are a few additional benefits of metal roofs:

Metal roofs tend to be much more durable

As mentioned above, metal roofs are more durable than shingles. It is said that a metal roof can last up to four times more than a shingle does. If a shingle’s average life span is 10-15 years, then the metal sheds would last more than 20-25 years with good quality material. They are tougher than shingles.

Metal roofs are cooler

This isn’t a benefit during the winters but can be of great help during the summers, especially in places where there is a lot of heat. As metal roofs tend to deflect the heat, they keep the shed and buildings much cooler.

Weather resistance

Metal roofs can actually bear through the heat from the sun as well as wind, snow, and hailstorms as well. It is good enough to resist the worst weather.


The metal roofs can come in a wide variety of colors which you can decide from. Deciding on a metal roof of your own choice can help you spice up a dull-looking place or storage space and make it look livelier. Unlike shingles, metal roofs aren’t that dull-looking.

Drawbacks of metal roofs

The metal roof has a lot of benefits, but at the same time, it has many drawbacks as well. There can be noise constraints, as well as budget constraints due to which one might refrain from getting metal roofs. The metal roofs are known to dent and scratch as well, especially when there is a huge amount of precipitation.

Cost constraints

Metals roofs are not as affordable as compared to shingles. They have a relatively higher cost, but one can bear with that due to the durability of the metal roof. However, many customers might not want to invest in an expensive material for the roof of a shed.


In case of heavy rainfall and hailstorms, the metal roof tends to be extremely loud. This also depends on the intensity of the rainfall. However, in most cases, it can be noisy, and customers despise that.

Comparing all of the pros and cons, when can say that metal roofing for the shed seems like the better option, but it mostly depends on the customer’s preferences.


In conclusion, one can say that a metal roof is much better than shingles in terms of durability and weather resistance.

However, if a customer is to decide between the two options, it is best to consider the weather of the place he/she lives in as well as the area of the shed. In the case of hot weather, the majority of times, using a metal shed might be smarter, and in the case of cold weather, a shingle would be better. 


No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *